Ellenbecker Personalized Medicine

Medical · November 1, 2026 · 6 min read

The Exercise Prescription

Quite possibly the most physically beneficial of the ten principles, exercise is also often the hardest for people to actually follow through on — and I'll fully admit I include myself in that group. The reason is almost always the same: it takes time, and time is the one thing none of us feel like we have enough of.

Here's the encouraging part, though: the evidence increasingly suggests we may not need nearly as much time as we used to think. Somewhere between 120 and 150 minutes a week — split between strength training, moderate cardiovascular activity, and something called NEAT (more on that in a moment) — appears to capture most of the benefit. Put another way: 120 minutes is about 1.2% of your week. That's the ask.

Why We Treat Exercise Differently Than Medication

I think part of why we're so quick to dismiss exercise, beyond the honest time constraints, is that we don't actually treat it like a prescription. When I tell a patient to take their blood pressure medication every day, most of them do it. When I tell that same patient we need to get them more active — say, strength training twice a week and a long, fast-paced walk five times a week — the follow-through is a completely different story.

A cardiologist friend of mine, Dr. Jake Kelly, wrote something on this exact idea that I think is worth reading in full: The Simplest Prescription I Write. He tells the story of Jeremy Morris, a physician who in 1953 noticed something odd about London's double-decker bus workers: the drivers, who sat all shift, were having heart attacks. The conductors, who climbed the stairs of those buses hundreds of times a shift collecting fares, largely weren't. Same buses, same routes, same era — the only meaningful difference was movement. It became one of the first rigorous pieces of evidence that physical activity itself prevents heart disease, and Jake makes the case that the prescription hasn't really changed since: move consistently, and the dose doesn't have to be heroic. If you enjoy his writing as much as I do, I'd encourage you to subscribe — he's one of the people who inspired me to start writing again in the first place.

That's really the model I want you to take from this post: exercise, written down and taken seriously, the same way you'd take a prescription.

The Three Types of Movement

Strength Training (2x a week, 20–30 minutes)

Strength training has long been thought of as something you do to build muscle or look a certain way, but the evidence on longevity tells a different story. A recent large study following nearly 150,000 people for up to 30 years found a clear "sweet spot": people who did roughly 90 to 120 minutes of strength training a week had about a 13% lower risk of dying from any cause, with a 19% lower risk of cardiovascular death and a 27% lower risk of death from neurological conditions like dementia. Interestingly, more wasn't necessarily better — the benefit leveled off beyond about two hours a week.

The real story is what muscle actually does in your body. It's one of your most metabolically active tissues, soaking up a large share of the sugar in your bloodstream after you eat, which helps protect against type 2 diabetes. Working muscles also release chemical messengers called myokines that help calm the low-grade inflammation tied to heart disease and cancer. And when strength training was combined with regular aerobic exercise, the reduction in death risk climbed to around 45%.

Cardiovascular Exercise (3x a week, 20–30 minutes, plus daily movement)

Moderate-intensity aerobic exercise can lower blood pressure for up to 13 hours afterward, ease anxiety symptoms almost immediately, improve insulin sensitivity, and help you fall asleep faster and sleep more deeply. One encouraging update to the guidelines: it doesn't have to come in long, uninterrupted sessions. Short bouts scattered throughout the day count toward the same weekly total — what matters most is the total amount of movement, not how it's packaged.

A large study tracking over 116,000 adults for up to 30 years found that going somewhat beyond the minimum recommendation brought even more benefit, but the key point for most patients isn't "more is always better" — it's that even modest, consistent activity above your current baseline moves the needle substantially, especially if you're starting from very little.

NEAT: The Movement You're Not Counting

NEAT stands for non-exercise activity thermogenesis — essentially, all the energy you burn through movement that isn't sleeping, eating, or formal exercise. Walking to your car, standing at your desk, doing yard work, carrying groceries, fidgeting — it all counts. The differences here are larger than most people expect: NEAT can vary by as much as 2,000 calories a day between two people of similar size, driven almost entirely by lifestyle and occupation.

This matters because formal exercise alone may not be enough to offset a day spent otherwise sitting. One study found that an hour of daily exercise couldn't fully compensate for the negative metabolic effects of sitting the rest of the day — and that reducing inactivity by walking or standing more was actually more effective than that same hour of formal exercise, when the total energy burned was held constant. Practical ways to build NEAT include taking the stairs, parking farther away, standing while on the phone, doing chores by hand instead of relying on machines, and simply walking more during the ordinary course of your day.

To know if your getting adequate exercise you have to know how hard to work. The good thing is that it doesn’t have to be grueling. First calculate your maximal heart rate (220 - age). Then target twice weekly 20-30 minutes activities at zone 2 (60% of your maximal heart rate) and once weekly 20 minute session at zone 5 (90% of your maximal heart rate).

The Exercise Prescription I Actually Write

For most of my patients starting from scratch, here's the prescription I give: strength training twice a week for 20 to 30 minutes per session, ideally at a pace that elevates your heart rate; a fast 20-minute walk two to three days a week (zone 2); and one additional 20-minute zone 5 cardiovascular session. It's not exotic, and it's not maximal — it's simply realistic enough that someone can actually sustain it, which is the entire point of a prescription in the first place.

Making 120 Minutes Realistic for a Busy Schedule

The honest math here matters. If you're commuting to a gym, the round trip alone can turn a 30-minute workout into a 90-minute commitment — which is exactly why so many good intentions quietly die on the drive there. A few ways to close that gap:

  • Walk part of your commute, if that's feasible — park farther away, get off transit a stop early, or walk instead of driving for short errands.

  • Use your lunch break for a brisk walk instead of a second scroll through your phone.

  • Skip the gym membership if it's the barrier. Most people can stay genuinely fit with a floor mat, a set of adjustable dumbbells (roughly 5 to 30 pounds), and either a bike or a decent pair of running shoes. None of that requires leaving the house.

Where are you starting from? Comment your current routine.

Sources: Jake Kelly, MD (jakekellymd.substack.com); Obesity Medicine Association; Harvard Health Publishing; American Medical Association; The Conversation / ScienceDaily.